Hello friends! I’m still continuing my Legends Reading Challenge, and I’ve finished The Old Republic Phase. I’ve done several posts of my thoughts on a few of them, but instead of doing more on the last few I’ve read, I’m just going to rank all the books in this phase with a few words about them. Let’s get started!
- The Darth Bane Trilogy, by Drew Karpyshyn. (5 out of 5 lightsabers). I did a review of Path of Destruction, but didn’t get to reviews of the other two books: Rule of Two and Dynasty of Evil. I did read them, however, and loved them, though the first book is my favorite of the three. The story of how Darth Bane radically reshaped the Sith is compelling reading, and though I’m Team Jedi all the way, these books are fantastic and helped me appreciate the history and beliefs of the Sith. Definitely number one on my list.
2. Deceived, by Paul S. Kemp. (4.5 out of 5 lightsabers). Check out my full thoughts here. I really liked this story of Darth Malgus, who loves a Twilek woman who was a former slave. The plot was fairly simple (which I appreciated, lol) but the main characters had to make tough decisions.
3. Annihilation, by Drew Karpyshyn. (3.5 out of 5 lightsabers). Check out my full thoughts here. I liked this one because it dealt with Theron Shan, a character who is descended from Revan and Bastila Shan, but who doesn’t have the Force. He relies on his own skills to stop a dangerous Sith and her ship/weapon. A good adventure. I gave this one 3.5 at the time of the original post, and now it’s above two 4-lightsabers books, lol, so I’m thinking it’s actually a 4.
4. Lost Tribe of the Sith, by John Jackson Miller. (4 out of 5 lightsabers). This is the last book of the Old Republic I read, and I didn’t think I’d like it, for some reason. But…I loved it! It’s a series of stories about several generations of Sith that crash-landed on a remote planet called Kesh 5,000 years BBY. The Sith on the ship Omen were working for Sith Lord Naga Sadow, but during a battle they were knocked into hyperspace off course, and crashed on a mountain on Kesh. The ship was destroyed, there were no communications, no one knew where they ended up so no one was coming, and there were very little metals on the planet, so no reparing anything. They were stuck. And they and their descendents stayed there for 5,000 years, conquering the native Keshiri. It was so interesting to see these Sith adapt and change over millenia, with no contact from the outside galaxy–no Republic, no Jedi, no aliens, just humans and Keshiri. Legends were born and reborn. But Sith will always be Sith, fighting each other for power. I was enthralled with the whole thing. Apparently, these stories are prequels to the Lost Tribe told about in the Legends books Fate of the Jedi (which I probably won’t get to for a long time, considering they’re towards the end of the Legends list, lol). I looked it up in Wookieepedia, and the Tribe does eventually get off Kesh to threaten the galaxy and deals with Luke Skywalker. Something to look forward to!
5. Revan, by Drew Karpyshyn. (4 out of 5 lightsabers). Check out my full thoughts here. I know some people absolutely love Revan, but I’m not one of them, lol. I don’t hate him, but I don’t see the fascination. Maybe it’s because I’m not a gamer. At any rate, the story was fine (I gave it 4 out of 5 lightsabers), but I do think it’s more appreciated if you’ve played the game.
6. Red Harvest, by Joe Schrieber. (3 out of 5 lightsabers). Check out my full thoughts here. Star Wars zombies! This was a fun and freaky Star Wars read. A Sith Sorceror seeks immortality but things go terribly wrong, naturally. A quick, bloody read with some interesting Star Wars elements.
7. Dawn of the Jedi, by Tim Lebbon. (3 out of 5 lightsabers). Check out my full thoughts here. This is the first Legends book I read in my Legends Reading Challenge, and the first on the timeline (25,000 BBY). It wasn’t exactly what I was hoping for, as it wasn’t the very beginning of the “Jed’aii,” but I guess that’s far enough back, lol.
8. Fatal Alliance, by Sean Williams. (3 out of 5 lightsabers). Check out my full thoughts here. This one took me awhile to get through, and had a lot going on. The weirdness factor was up there, too, lol. Not bad, but not great, either.
9. Knight Errant, by John Jackson Miller. (2 out of 5 lightsabers). Confession: I didn’t finish this book. Doesn’t seem fair to give it a rating because of this, but based on what I read, I’d give it a 2 (and that’s only because I normally respect the author, lol). It pains me to do this, as I’ve enjoyed plenty of other John Jackson Miller books (Kenobi, Rebel Dawn, and Lost Tribe of the Sith). And it’s a really cool cover. But it was just so incredibly boring. There’s no other way to say it. I didn’t particularly like the Jedi protagonist, it took forever for things to get going (and by the middle of the book, it still hadn’t), the plot was confusing and weird, and I just didn’t want to waste any more time on it. I just didn’t care. I’m sad about it, but it happens. There were some comics that went along with it (and even a portion of the comic inserted into the middle of the book), but it didn’t help me like it any better. Maybe someday I’ll finish it…but I doubt it, lol.
So that wraps up the first Legends section of The Old Republic. Next up: “The Rise of the Sith Era” with Cloak of Deception, by James Luceno. Back into more familiar territory, and I’m looking forward to it! Stay tuned.
Star Wars and Other Obsessions 